Lessons Learned From Ancient Greece

By Lila Joffe ’21, Contributor

Ninth-grade students started the year studying different forms of government in ancient civilizations in their history classes. One of the recent areas of focus in Dr. McCall’s Ancient World History class has been the Ancient Greek Polis. While at first glance, this form of government seems like a distant and irrelevant model, upon further study, there are many intriguing aspects of this ancient form of government. As we are constantly reminded of the current dysfunction of our political system and government, it is hard not to compare our system to those of the past.  We are bombarded with reminders of the divisions in our country and politicians’ inability to properly govern as a result. Perhaps looking to the past for inspiration is not such a bad idea.

According to Dr. McCall, an interesting feature of the Ancient Athenian Polis was the ability for all citizens to participate fully in their government. Citizens were invited to directly participate in the form of an assembly to aid in the improvement of government. They were also able to elect and review generals and, if necessary, even impeach and exile those generals.  Athenian citizens were required to be males born of two Athenian parents. Allowing all people to participate in these elections was very influential in other forms of government that have followed throughout history.

The Athenian citizens had a direct representation in their government. In the U.S. government, citizens elect representatives to participate in Congress and the Senate. Citizens have to trust that these politicians will represent their individual interests and beliefs. Politicians often spend more time and energy worrying about getting re-elected rather than truly fighting for the best interests of their voters.

With the current political system in the U.S., it is not difficult to contemplate how things would be different if citizens had the same rights as those of the Athenian Polis. If women were not excluded, the model of a polis would be similar to the United States. Part of the challenge in the United States is getting people to vote. If citizens were able to actually vote on laws, then government participation would skyrocket. Many Americans are frustrated and would welcome the idea of having a louder voice and a more direct impact on the rule of law.

 ** this information has been taken and interpreted from ancient sources, this article is using the information cautiously**